Israel’s Gen-Z Conscientious Objectors: Choosing Principles Over Military Service

The Dilemma of Conscription

Israel's mandatory conscription for most Jewish Israelis has long been a topic of discussion and contemplation among the younger generation. While exemptions are granted on various grounds, the pressure to serve in the Israel Defense Forces (IDF) is deeply ingrained in society. However, a growing number of Gen-Z conscientious objectors are challenging this norm and facing severe consequences for their refusal to join the army.

A Shift in Perspective

Tal Mitnick, an 18-year-old, had once believed that serving in the IDF was inevitable. It was a societal expectation he had internalized since childhood. However, as he grew older, he began questioning the notion of national duty. Mitnick's perspective took a significant turn when he came across footage of settler violence and anti-occupation organizations online. This exposure compelled him to reject any form of IDF service, viewing it as a contribution to the "cycle of violence" with Palestinians.

Embracing Unpopular Stances

By openly identifying as a "refusenik," Mitnick is willingly embracing a controversial position in a society deeply rooted in militarism. He understands that his decision may lead to the loss of friendships and potentially land him behind bars. Mitnick is currently awaiting sentencing by a military tribunal, fully aware that he may face imprisonment in an army facility.

A Journey of Activism

Yuval Dag, a 21-year-old who spent 64 days in a military prison for refusing to serve, shares a similar story. Growing up in a staunchly Zionist household, his perspective shifted as he encountered alternative viewpoints on social media. Dag credits platforms like Instagram for providing him with news and perspectives beyond Israeli propaganda. Through exposure to footage from Palestinian citizen journalists and on-the-ground activists, Dag believes that Gen-Z Israelis now have unprecedented access to the realities of life in Gaza and the West Bank.

The Power of Social Media

For Israeli conscientious objectors like Sofia Orr and Iddo Elam, social media has become a vital tool for publicly expressing their refusals. By vocalizing their objections online, they hope to encourage other young Israelis to reconsider their decisions to serve. While acknowledging the social cost and potential ostracization that comes with refusing to enlist, Orr and Elam remain steadfast in their desire to reject the system.

Inspiring Change

Despite the discouragement they face from friends and family, Mitnick, Orr, and Elam are determined to inspire others to question the status quo. They believe that if even one person chooses not to join the army for political reasons, it is a small victory. These Gen-Z conscientious objectors are willing to face the consequences, including imprisonment, in the pursuit of their principles.

As Israel grapples with the growing number of young people opting out of military service, it raises important questions about the role of individual conscience in a society deeply intertwined with its military. The bravery and determination of these conscientious objectors challenge societal norms and pave the way for a more nuanced conversation about national duty and the pursuit of peace.

—————————————————————————————————————————————
By: jzitser@businessinsider.com (Joshua Zitser)
Title: Israel’s Gen-Z Conscientious Objectors: Choosing Principles Over Military Service
Sourced From: www.businessinsider.com/israel-gen-z-facing-prison-ostracization-refusing-join-idf-gaza-2023-12
Published Date: Fri, 15 Dec 2023 09:54:35 +0000